How do we talk about issues that matter?
I feel like a lot of times, especially in today's society, there are two ways we go about talking about the issues that matter. Some of us only talk about the issues we feel matter to us, and others tend to avoid these types of conversations as a whole. But how do we get everyone to talk about everything? We need to advocate for not only the issues themselves, but for the attention they require. It is very important that we continue to advocate for what is important to us, even if we feel we may be too "loud" or "annoying."
Example, I could go to a protest for women's rights on Saturday, post that I was there, and never speak of it again. What good would this do for the cause? It would be forgotten as soon as the post is deleted. However, if I were to speak about my experience at the protest and the reason for it to my friends, family, associates, etc., it would bring attention to the issue/topic which would lead them to sharing their awareness with their peers and so on.
Now, I know that it is easier said than done, but there are also other ways to talk about the issues that matter. In the classroom, many teachers may be afraid to bring up the topic of these issues, but I feel that if it is done in the right way, everybody will be able to have their voices heard, learn from their peers, and maybe even learn about an issue that they had no idea even existed. We can talk about them in the classroom by dedicating a bit of time everyday to speak about current events, how they affect us personally, and what we think could be done to resolve them. This could promote a safe space for students to be able to share how they truly feel. However, as teachers, we do need to set certain rules and guidelines to avoid students directly trying to offend their peers.
Something that helped me come to this conclusion was Dr. Steven Becton's article, After Eric Garner: One School's Courageous Conversation. Reading about Dr. Becton's experience was very eye opening as to how issues in our society affect us negatively whenever we avoid talking about them. When speaking out about the issues in our society that we have strong emotions about, we are allowing ourselves to be heard and are opening up conversation about a topic that many people would usually try to avoid.
Hi San Juanita! I agree that lots of people tread lightly on issues that truly matter. I feel that by posting your experience at a march or protest, it shows you stand for the cause, but so does everyone else who attended. So how can we really do something to support a certain cause? I think that by bringing up “controversial” topic’s teachers can provide a place for students to feel included and welcomed. But it could also make students feel uncomfortable, but sometimes we all need to feel uncomfortable to learn something new and take a walk in somebody else’s shoes. When these students are feeling uncomfortable, they can share their opinions with their peers, and they can be heard. I agree that we should dedicate time to speak on the issues that matter in class, but once that 20 minutes is over, will the students remember the importance of the issue?
ReplyDeleteHello San Juanita, I really liked your blog because it had some good ideas. I totally agree that people will either completely ignore topics they don't want to talk about or just talk about the topics they like.I really liked your example of the march because it is a great thing to go and post about it to get the recognition it deserves but sometimes people don't realize there is so much more they can do. I think talking about current events in the classroom is a great idea because not only does it allow students to talk about how it makes them feel but it also educates them on what is going on in the world.
DeleteHi Schuyler! That you so much for your reply to my post! I agree with your idea on how sometimes we all need to feel uncomfortable to learn something new. Although some of the controversial topics in our society are usually the opposite of "sunshine and rainbows" (for lack of better wording), it is important for us to acknowledge why we feel the way we do about them, and address what we can do to resolve the issue. I also like how you added the thought of students forgetting the importance of the issue after the class time where we speak about them is over. I think that is it impossible to force every single student to carry what we discuss in the classroom with them forever. However, I do believe that if even just one student carries what we discussed during class time with them throughout their lives, it was a success.
DeleteHi Maya! Thank you so much for your reply! I think it is very important for people to be able to talk about the issues that they are interested in, but it is also equally, if not more important for them to talk about the ones that they tend to avoid. It is so important for students to be able to learn in an environment where they are also able to share how they feel safely.
DeleteHi San Juanita! I really enjoyed reading your blog because I really did agree to everything you mentioned. In todays society, it is nothing like it used to be. I feel like over the years it became more and more difficult to talk about issues that matter. I think you made a great point mentioning that a teacher should make time out of the day to talk with their students about issues that matter. Everyone has a voice, and I think the students would enjoy expressing it. Although not everyone might have the same mindset, it's good to discuss with one another to learn more about the topic.I also agree that there should be set rules and guidelines. Some people may take it too far or take things a little more personal. Its important that the students keep safe enough to express their opinions. I think a classroom might be the best bet when discussing issues that matter, and I truly believe that's how it always should be.
ReplyDeleteHi Ashley! Thank you for replying! I agree with your thought on how whenever we get older it gets harder for us to talk about issues that matter. I think that this is because as we grow older, we realize the true effects these issues have on people in this world and are too afraid to add to the suffering or say the wrong thing. I loved hearing about your opinion on the classroom being the best bet when discussing issue that matter because I agree. If the students begin practicing considering others' opinions and speaking out about what they believe in at a young age, I think that they will confidently continue with it throughout their lives.
DeleteHi San Juanita, your blog has a lot of good points on the issues that matter. Your example on the protest is very much true because I feel that happens a lot. Some people just attend a certain thing just because their friends are going, or because it's trending. Yet they don't truly understand what they're marching for or against. I really like your way to allow students to voice their thoughts and opinions at the end of every day is brilliant. This will let students be more open and discuss the things that are happening in today's world. Thus, hearing their classmates' thoughts and opinions on the topic. Now, what would you do for the students who don't want to participate? Perhaps, having a closed, locked box that allows those students to put their thoughts in without anyone knowing. And yes, setting rules where other students can't offend or disrespect their classmates is important. This way students don't get discouraged or hurt and make them not want to discuss out loud anymore. I'll have to give that article you mentioned a read.
ReplyDeleteHi Angelica! Thank you for your reply! Honestly, I hadn't put much thought into if a student didn't want to participate, so thank you for asking. I understand why a student would not want to participate, and if it were only a few I think I would try my best to work with them individually to see what they are and are not comfortable with. If it were many students, I think I would then have to rethink my approach on how we go about talking about the issues that matter in the classroom. I love your idea of having a box where students will be able to put their thoughts without anyone knowing! I think it would give all students an opportunity to be heard without being afraid of what others might think.
DeleteHello San Juanita, I love your post and just think I couldn't have said it any better myself. I really liked how you spoke on setting rules for students. These rules making sure students don't disrespect our students is important. We can teach them respect all day long but to teach disrespect is just as important. Taking a second to talk about what's happening now is important. You can advocate all day long and protest but why wouldn't you go spreading the word every chance you get to every person you interact with. I like the article you referred to it really focuses on avoiding hard issues only hurts us not helps us. Promoting a safe environment for our students to speak on what they believe is important and part of our jobs as educators. This safe place can come with difficulties that we must do our best to avoid.
ReplyDeleteHi Hanna! Thank you for your reply! I also think that teaching about disrespect is just as important as respect. Many times, a student many accidentally disrespect one of their peers, not because they meant to, but because they genuinely did not know that they were. By teaching the importance of disrespect and its effects, we can avoid many problems in the classroom.
Delete